Connect with us

Hot!

Ambulance trial: AG objects to admissibility of recording for cross-examination

Published

on

The High Court in Accra is expected to on Thursday, June 13 decide on whether to admit into evidence or not, an audio recording of a conversation between Godfred Yeboah Dame and the third accused person in the ongoing ambulance case, Richard Jakpa.

This is after lawyers for minority leader, Dr. Cassiel Ato Forson submitted the audio in an attempt to cross-examine Richard Jakpa on his claims that the Attorney General has been engaging him at odd hours to implicate Ato Forson.

SIMILARITY OF AUDIO

The audio, which was served on all parties prior to the sitting except for lawyers for Richard Jakpa was played in open court. Justice Afia Serwah Asare-Botwe asked for the tape to be played to ‘verify if what was served is the same as the one before the court and if the audio is admissible’

Advertisement

The audio was confirmed by the prosecution to be the one served on them, as well as the one tendered for the mistrial application, which was dismissed by the court.

Channel One News notes that the tape was substantially similar to the one aired by the National Democratic Congress (NDC) at its recent press conference on the matter.

OBJECTION BY PROSECUTION

The prosecution, however, objected to the admissibility of the audio in evidence. Arguing for the state, the director of public prosecution, Yvonne Attakora-Obuobisa noted, that even though the tape was earlier admitted by the same court to dispose off the mistrial application, it does not in the current circumstance pose any relevance to the main trial.

Advertisement

Ms. Attakora-Obuobisa indicated that the tape was only admitted then because it was relevant for the court to determine if the Attorney General sought to ask Richard Jakpa to incriminate Dr. Cassiel Ato Forson. She reminded the court that ‘negligible weight’ was even put on it.

She then argued that in the current instance and in accordance with section 51 of the evidence ACT, the tape is ‘extremely irrelevant”.

According to her, the recording discusses matters of the issuance of the letters of credit and those issues, in her opinion, are already before the court through the cross-examination of the witnesses of Ato Forson like Alex Mould and Seth Terkper, as well as evidence adduced by prosecution witnesses.

She was of the firm view that ‘the recording is of no significance whatsoever in arriving at any decision in respect of the actions of the accused person (Ato Forson) that has resulted in financial loss or the intentional misapplication of public funds’

Advertisement

To make the audio admissible, Yvonne Attakora Obuobisa also made the point that the lawyers of Ato Forson need to prove that the recording does not breach any provisions of the constitution. She cites Article 18(2) of the 1992 Constitution, which guarantees the right to privacy.

The Director of Public Prosecution asserts that the audio recording does not meet the exception of recording without consent to prevent a crime.

To her, the lawyers of Dr. Cassiel Ato Forson have not been able to prove any crime the Attorney General was committing or about to commit for which the recording ought to be done without the consent of the Attorney General.

RESPONSE BY LAWYERS OF ATO FORSON

Advertisement

Dr. Abdul Bassit Aziz Bamba who led the lawyers for the minority leader, however, described the objection as ‘frivolous, untenable and be overruled’. He argues that the content of the recording is relevant as it relates to discussions on exhibits already before the court that deals with the supply agreement for the ambulances as well as the authorisation.

He posits further that the tape is relevant as to when the Letters of Credit should have been established and whether any financial loss at all has been caused to the state.

He makes reference to the content of the tape stating that it can be heard on the tape, that Dr. Sylvester Anemana, who was the second accused in the matter, until a Nolle Prosequi was entered with respect to his case, was the one who authorised the Letters of Credit and not Dr. Ato Forson.

Dr. Bassit Bamba also impressed upon the court to determine the tape admissible on grounds that the ‘same reasons and more’ for which the court assigned relevance to the tape in considering their application for mistrial exists in the current circumstance.

Advertisement

Lawyers of Ato Forson also asked the court to admit the audio into evidence as the engagement is between Richard Jakpa and the Attorney General who is a public officer and expected to carry out his mandate in good faith.

It is the view of the lawyers that the Attorney General was seeking to subvert the right of their client to fair trial.

Dr. Bassit Bamba also disagreed with the prosecution’s view, that the recording without the consent of the Attorney General breaches Godfred Dame’s right to privacy.

He contends that the actions of the Attorney General in attempting to push his theory of the case on Richard Jakpa constitute interference with the administration of justice and amounts to contempt of court.

Advertisement

He argues further that the Attorney General’s action relates to a crime of willful suppression contrary to the dictates of sections 239 and 246 of the Criminal and offences ACT, 29.

ADJOURNMENT

Justice Afia Serwah Asare-Botwe after hearing the arguments of the two sides adjourned the case to Thursday to deliver a ruling on the admissibility of the audio.

Source: Citinewsroom.com

Advertisement

Continue Reading
Advertisement

Hot!

Heartfelt Philanthropy Network, Elevate Africa fellows support Street Academy

Published

on

Mr Ashie Kotey (in suit) with Dr Lartey (third left) and fellows of the network

The Heartfelt Philanthropy Network and fellows of Elevate Africa Fellowship have visited the Street Academy in Accra to support its efforts to improve the welfare and development of children.

The visit formed part of efforts by the organisations to give back to the community and promote opportunities for children through education, healthcare and other social support programmes.

Ms Yvonne Abba-Opoku, Founder and Director of the Heartfelt Philanthropy Network, said the organisation had supported the Street Academy since 2019 because of its commitment to serving vulnerable children. Read More.

SKIP THE QUEUE, TAP THE NEWS

Advertisement

You can now read the Ghanaian Times and The Spectator newspapers from the comfort of your device via TimesNewsPlus.

Buy Maps

Join our WhatsApp Channel: https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029VbBElzjInlqHhl1aTU27

Continue Reading

Hot!

Afia Akoto declares intent to contest Okaikwei North NPP Parliamentary primaries

Published

on

Alberta Afia Asomaniwa Akoto, popularly known as “Landlady,” has declared her intention to contest as the Parliamentary Candidate for the New Patriotic Party (NPP) in the Okaikwei North Constituency.

In a statement shared on Friday, Ms. Akoto said Okaikwei North has been her home for more than 40 years, where she has lived among the people, shared in their joys and challenges, and built lasting connections with the community.

“I am in the race because I believe our community deserves dedicated service, a listening ear and a strong voice. I am ready to work with you, listen to your concerns and help build a brighter future for Okaikwei North,” she said.

“Dear Okaikwei North, your girl is here one of your own, ready to serve,” she added.

Advertisement

Ms. Akoto said service is not just a responsibility but a commitment to the people and the community they call home.

Having dedicated herself to serving and supporting the people of the constituency, she said she wishes to continue the journey of service with renewed commitment, greater dedication and a stronger vision.

Her vision, she noted, is to build on the progress made, listen to the concerns of the people, empower the youth, support women, create opportunities and champion development that benefits every community in the constituency.

“I believe that together, we can build a stronger, more prosperous and inclusive Okaikwei North,” she added.

Advertisement

By Edem Mensah-Tsotorme

Continue Reading
Advertisement

Trending